How to Have Difficult Conversations at Work
How to have difficult conversations at work, understand the psychology behind conflict avoidance and explore practical examples for new and experienced leaders.
Kim Cutler
11/19/20269 min read


My post content
It's 3am and I'm having a conversation with someone who isn't even in the room.
I'm rehearsing what I'm going to say, anticipating how they might respond and preparing my response to their response. I've probably played out half a dozen different scenarios, none of which may ever happen.
Sound familiar?
Despite years of coaching leaders and a background in psychology, I'm not immune to the discomfort that comes with difficult conversations, particularly when there's the potential for conflict.
But what is it about these conversations that makes us so uncomfortable? And why do we often expend more time and emotional energy avoiding them than it would take to actually have them?
Why do we avoid difficult conversations at work?
Whether you've recently stepped into a leadership position or have been leading people for years, difficult conversations can still feel incredibly uncomfortable.
In my work with leaders, it's not unusual to uncover some of the following concerns:
What if this changes things between us forever?
What if they go and tell other people?
What if this changes what they, or others, think of me?
What if they turn it around on me?
What if I get upset or can't hold my own?
Am I being too harsh? Am I making a bigger deal of this than I need to?
What if I'm actually the problem?
Can I just let it go this time?
Perhaps if I leave it a little longer, things will sort themselves out?
We're not necessarily avoiding the conversation itself. We're avoiding how we anticipate the conversation might make us feel.
There's nothing wrong with wanting people to like you. But when your need to be liked starts influencing the decisions you make as a leader, whose needs are you actually prioritising?
There's an interesting bit of psychology at play here called negative reinforcement. When we put off something that makes us uncomfortable, we experience a sense of relief. That relief reinforces our avoidance behaviour, making us more likely to do the same thing again.
The problem, of course, is that whilst we feel better for a little while, the issue itself rarely disappears.
Research published by Acas on informal conflict resolution at work highlights that managers worry about making situations worse, damaging working relationships and their own ability to manage conflict. Yet addressing issues early can help preserve those relationships.
There's a certain irony in that, isn't there? In trying to protect a relationship, we may inadvertently be undermining it.
The hidden cost of avoiding difficult conversations
Let's start with sleep. Or the lack of it.
The mental load of an unresolved issue can be significant. We replay interactions, rehearse conversations, second-guess ourselves and spend time talking to other people about the situation rather than speaking to the person concerned.
And let's not even get started on what happens after we've had the conversation. We lie awake ruminating over what we should have said, what we could have done differently, whether we were too harsh or not direct enough, and what the other person must now be thinking of us.
I'm sure I'm not alone in coming up with some of my most articulate responses several hours after they'd have been of any use whatsoever.
Before, during and after the conversation, it can take up an extraordinary amount of headspace.
But as a leader, you're not the only one paying the price for your avoidance.
Other team members may be picking up the slack of an underperforming colleague. Resentment may be building. Poor behaviour goes unchecked and gradually becomes the norm. People may begin to question your leadership.
And what about the individual concerned?
By withholding honest feedback, you may be denying someone the opportunity to learn, develop or put something right. They may be completely unaware that there's an issue in the first place.
By the time we eventually have the conversation, we might have spent six weeks getting increasingly irritated by someone's behaviour. They've had approximately six seconds to get their head around the fact that there's even a problem. Is it any wonder we're entering the conversation in very different places emotionally?
Is avoiding the conversation really the kinder thing to do?
How to prepare for a difficult conversation at work
Preparation is important, but there's a difference between preparing for a conversation and trying to control how it will unfold.
You cannot predict exactly how someone else will respond, nor can you script both sides of the conversation.
What you can do is give some thought to your own part in all of this.
Before having a difficult conversation, consider the following questions:
What's actually bothering me?
What have I seen or heard and what am I assuming?
Who is this affecting and how?
What part might I have played in this?
Have I been clear about what I expect?
What might I not know?
What do I want to come out of this conversation?
There's a big difference between what we've seen and what we've made it mean.
There is a considerable difference between saying someone is disengaged and observing that they haven't contributed to the last three team meetings.
One is a judgement. The other is something you can actually have a conversation about.
Give some thought to how you're feeling going into the conversation, too. If you're frustrated, angry or determined to prove a point, how might that influence the way you listen and respond?
Examples of difficult conversations at work
One of the biggest challenges can be knowing how to get the conversation started. Here are five common workplace scenarios and some alternative ways of approaching them.
These aren't scripts to follow word for word, but they might help you think differently about how you open a conversation.
1. How to have a difficult conversation with an employee about performance
Rather than:
"Your performance hasn't been good enough recently."
You might try:
"Can we have a chat about the reports? The last three have come in late and it's starting to hold other people up. Is there something going on that I'm not aware of?"
Be clear about what's not working, but allow for space to understand why.
Does the person have the skills, resources and support they need? Are priorities clear? Are there competing demands you're unaware of?
Understanding why something is happening doesn't mean letting someone off the hook. It means you're better equipped to do something about it.
2. How to have a difficult conversation with an employee about their attitude
I'm always a little curious when a leader describes someone as having a 'bad attitude'.
What does that actually mean?
Rather than:
"I've noticed you've got a really negative attitude at the moment."
You might try:
"I wanted to pick up on something from yesterday's meeting. There were a couple of occasions when you spoke over people before they'd finished. Did you notice that? I'm interested to hear how you felt the meeting went."
Labelling someone is unlikely to lead to a useful conversation. You're more likely to get resistance or challenge.
Talk about what they've done, the impact it's having and what needs to change, rather than making a judgement about who they are as a person.
3. Managing someone who regularly challenges you
Being challenged as a leader can feel uncomfortable, particularly if you're relatively new to the role or are now managing people who were previously your peers.
But someone challenging your thinking isn't necessarily problematic.
Is it the fact that they're challenging you, or the way in which they're doing it?
Rather than:
"I need you to stop questioning my decisions in front of the team."
You might try:
"Can we talk about what happened in the meeting earlier? I don't mind you disagreeing with me, and I certainly don't expect us to agree on everything, but I didn't feel particularly comfortable with the way that conversation played out. How did you see it?"
It's worth asking yourself whether it's your decision that's being challenged or whether you feel your authority is being undermined.
The two aren't the same thing.
4. How to have a difficult conversation with your boss
Difficult conversations aren't always about managing people who report to you. Sometimes the person you need to speak to is the person you report to.
Perhaps you're struggling with competing priorities, unrealistic expectations or a lack of support.
Rather than:
"You keep giving me more work and expecting me to get everything done."
You might try:
"I'm struggling a bit with the amount I've got on at the moment. I want to do a good job, but realistically I can't give everything the same level of attention. Can we sit down and work out what needs to take priority?"
Managing upwards is an important leadership skill. Your boss might not have a clue how much you've taken on, particularly if you've become very good at saying yes to everything without raising concerns. A common trap of the newbie leader.
5. Addressing conflict between team members
It can be tempting to step in, solve the problem and get everyone back to work.
But how much do you really understand about what's happening between the individuals concerned?
Rather than:
"You two need to put your differences aside and get on with it."
You might try:
"Things have felt a bit tense between you two in the last few meetings. I might be reading it wrong, but it's starting to affect the rest of the team. Can we talk about what's going on?"
Depending on the circumstances, it might be more appropriate to speak to each person individually before bringing them together.
Resist the temptation to work out who's right and who's wrong before you've properly understood the situation.
Sometimes your job is simply to help two people have a conversation they're struggling to have on their own. You don't have to resolve every disagreement yourself.
Of course, not everything can or should be sorted out over a chat. If you're dealing with serious concerns around bullying, harassment, discrimination or misconduct, speak to HR and follow the appropriate procedures.
How to handle difficult conversations when emotions are involved
Somewhere along the way, many of us seem to have adopted the belief that a successful conversation is one in which nobody gets upset.
I'm not sure that's a particularly helpful measure.
People may feel disappointed, frustrated, embarrassed or angry. You might experience some of those emotions yourself.
Part of being a leader is learning to sit with the uncomfortable stuff without feeling the need to fix it.
Here are some things to consider during the conversation:
Actually listen. Are you hearing what they're saying or are you already thinking about what you're going to say next?
Don't rush to fill the silence just because it feels awkward. Give them a moment to think.
Catch yourself if you start getting defensive or feel the need to justify yourself.
You don't have to agree with someone to understand why they might feel the way they do.
Be prepared to change your mind. You might not have the full story.
Don't backtrack or water down what you've said just because you're uncomfortable with their response.
If someone becomes upset, it doesn't automatically mean you've handled the conversation badly.
Equally, being direct doesn't give you permission to disregard the impact you're having on someone else.
You can be understanding and supportive and hold someone accountable at the same time.
What happens after a difficult conversation?
Having the conversation is only part of the work.
It's not unusual for two people to leave the same meeting with quite different interpretations of what has been discussed and agreed.
Before wrapping up the conversation, make sure you're both on the same page. Keep it simple:
What have we covered?
What do we need to do now?
How are we going to do it?
Who will do what?
How and when are we going to check in on this?
And then follow through.
If you've raised a concern about someone's performance or behaviour but never revisit it, what message does that send?
It's also worth taking a few minutes to reflect on your own contribution to the conversation. What went well? What surprised you? What did you learn about yourself? What might you do differently next time?
There's a difference between reflecting on a conversation and ruminating over it. One is about learning from what happened. The other is repeatedly putting yourself through something that's already happened.
By all means, consider what you might do differently next time, but there's little to be gained from mentally beating yourself up for the next three days.
Unfortunately, the only way to really get better at having difficult conversations is to actually have them.
So, what conversation are you avoiding?
Perhaps there's a conversation you've been putting off for a few days. Or perhaps it's been weeks, months or even longer.
What's really stopping you?
What are you protecting yourself from?
And what is the cost of continuing to avoid it, both to you and to those around you?
Leadership isn't about becoming immune to discomfort. It's about recognising when our own discomfort is influencing our behaviour and making a conscious decision about what we do next.
And who knows, you might even get a better night's sleep.
Much of my work as an executive and leadership coach involves exploring the stuff that doesn't necessarily get talked about at work. The self-doubt, the frustrations, the relationship challenges and the conversations we'd rather not have.
If you'd benefit from having somewhere to work through some of this stuff yourself, I'd love to have a chat.
About the author
Kim Storm McQueen Cutler is an ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC), executive and leadership coach and founder of Storm McQueen Coaching. With a BSc (Hons) in Psychology and a background in financial services, she works with leaders across a range of industries, from those stepping into leadership for the first time to senior executives.
Storm McQueen
Executive coaching and leadership development for people stepping into greater responsibility
Home | For Organisations | For Individuals | About | Contact
kim@stormmcqueen.com
Based in Suffolk | Working with leaders across the UK
© 2026 Storm McQueen-| Privacy & Legal
